If you’re looking for cheap auto insurance Illinois USA, cheap car insurance Illinois, or just inexpensive auto insurance Illinois USA, knowing which companies tend to offer lower rates for reliable coverage can help you save. Based on recent data, here are 5 companies that often show up among the most affordable options. We’ll rank them from #1 (cheapest on average) to #5, discuss typical prices, and explain why they are considered good for cheap insurance car insurance Illinois USA.
1. GEICO Insurance
Typical Pricing in Illinois
- For full coverage (good driver, clean record, 40-year-old, decent credit), GEICO’s average annual premium in Illinois is about $1,178/year or roughly $98/month data from Insure.com.
- For minimum liability coverage, GEICO is among the cheaper options, though not always the absolute lowest.
Why GEICO is “cheap” / Inexpensive
- GEICO tends to have lower overhead due to its strong online / direct marketing model, which helps reduce costs.
- It offers many discounts (good driver, multiple vehicles, bundling, etc.), which reduce effective premium for many drivers.
- Its scale: large customer base allows spreading risk and cost.
2. Travelers Insurance
Typical Pricing in Illinois
- For full coverage, Travelers is frequently listed as the cheapest large insurer, with about $1,119/year (~$93/month) for the standard profile noted by Insure.com.
- For minimum coverage, rates with Travelers often are the lowest or near-lowest; for example: approximately $523/year (~$44/month) for minimum liability policies.
Why Travelers is Considered Cheap
- Strong discounts for safe driving, bundling, and perhaps credit level or location help reduce premiums.
- Competitive underwriting and pricing in Illinois helps; in many markets, Travelers is willing to offer lower rates to attract business.
- They often perform well in data comparisons for cheap vehicle insurance Illinois USA for various driver types.
3. Auto-Owners Insurance
Typical Pricing in Illinois
- According to Insure.com, Auto-Owners shows average full coverage for Illinois for $1,426/year (~$119/month) in some data sets.
- For many driver profiles (clean record, good credit), Auto-Owners ranks well in MoneyGeek as “best overall car insurance in Illinois” with about $75/month for full coverage in that profile.
Why Auto-Owners is Affordable
- Good customer satisfaction may reduce loss ratios (fewer disputes, better claims handling) which helps keep premiums lower.
- Offers various discounts, perhaps less aggressive pricing but more stable rates.
- Often strong local-agent network and stable underwriting lead to better risk selection.
-
Erie Insurance
Typical Pricing in Illinois
- Erie’s full coverage average in Illinois is higher than the very lowest, but still below many competitors. For example, in Insure.com’s breakdown Erie shows ~$1,489/year (~$124/month) for full coverage.
- For drivers with violations or special cases, Erie sometimes becomes more affordable relative to other large insurers. Also ranked well for customer service.
Why Erie Can Be Cheap for Certain Drivers
- Offers tailored policies that may favor lower-risk drivers in less dense or lower-claim areas.
- Because Erie is regional (stronger in certain states/areas), they may have lower claims costs in those regions, enabling lower premiums.
- Their customer service / policyholder satisfaction tends to be good, which indirectly reduces costs (fewer lawsuits, lower administrative overhead).
5. State Farm Insurance
Typical Pricing in Illinois
- For full coverage, State Farm averages around $1,633/year (~$136/month) according to data from Insure.com.
- For minimum coverage, State Farm often has rates close to the cheaper half; though often not the absolute lowest, but good services and agent availability make them a popular trade-off.
Why State Farm is Affordable / Good Value
- Large network, economy of scale, bundle discounts (home/auto, multiple vehicles) help bring down net costs.
- Strong brand, strong claims process, many agents in Illinois – good accessibility.
- Many drivers find State Farm gives reliable coverage without extreme premiums, especially in suburban or rural parts of Illinois where claim frequency is lower.
Illinois Average Rates & How These Fit
To put this in perspective, here are some average cost benchmarks for cheap insurance Illinois USA:
- The average full coverage premium in Illinois is about $1,799/year (~$150/month) based on a clean-record driver.
- The average minimum liability insurance (state-required) is around $768/year (~$64/month).
- Some of the companies above (Travelers, GEICO, Auto-Owners) are well below those averages for many drivers.
So when you see, say, Travelers: $1,119/year or GEICO: ~$1,178/year, you know those are good rates for full coverage under favorable circumstances. These are examples of cheap car auto insurance Illinois USA, though your actual rate will depend heavily on your driver profile, location, vehicle, etc.
Why These Companies Are “Cheap” in Illinois
Some common reasons these carriers can provide cheap vehicle insurance Illinois USA:
- Driver Profile Matching – If you have a clean driving record, good credit, live in a lower-risk ZIP code, these companies will give you better pricing.
- Discounts – Safe driver discounts, bundling (auto + home), multiple vehicles, low mileage, anti-theft devices, etc., can reduce premiums significantly.
- Coverage Choices – Choosing higher deductibles, limiting optional coverages (but ensuring legal minimums), choosing liability-only when allowed, etc., helps reduce costs.
- Scale & Efficiency – Larger insurers or those with efficient online tools can reduce administrative costs or marketing expenses and pass along savings.
- Local Risk Factors – Insurers consider theft rates, accident frequency, weather risks, repair costs. Regions of Illinois outside big cities may have fewer claims and lower risk, which helps.
- Regulatory Environment – Illinois has had periods where insurance rates dropped or were moderated; some companies adjust aggressively to stay competitive.
FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)
Here are some common questions people ask when looking for cheap cheap car insurance Illinois USA, cheap auto insurance online Illinois USA, etc.
Q1: What is the cheapest way to get auto insurance in Illinois?
- Choose the minimum required liability coverage if that suits your needs and is legal for you.
- Maintain a clean driving record.
- Look for discounts (safe driver, bundling).
- Shop around—get quotes from multiple companies (GEICO, Travelers, State Farm, etc.).
- Consider a higher deductible.
Q2: Is it cheaper to buy car insurance online in Illinois?
- Often yes, because online tools reduce administrative overhead. But not always—some discounts require agent contact.
Q3: How much does bad credit or a DUI increase insurance in Illinois?
- Significantly. For example, with bad credit, some companies’ annual premiums can jump well above state averages.
- After a DUI, companies like Travelers may still offer relatively lower premium compared to others, but the cost is substantially more than clean record rates.
Q4: Can teens get affordable car insurance in Illinois?
- Insurance for teen drivers is expensive. Some companies are cheaper (Country Financial, Travelers, Auto-Owners) for younger drivers. But it’s still multiple times higher than what adult drivers pay.
Q5: What is the “cheapest automobile insurance Illinois USA” for non-owner drivers or SR-22?
- Auto-Owners offers some of the most affordable non-owner policies (for those who drive but don’t own a vehicle) and relatively low SR-22 policy rates among major insurers.
Conclusion
If you are searching for cheap auto insurance Illinois USA, these five companies — GEICO, Travelers, Auto-Owners, Erie Insurance, and State Farm — are among the best starting points. Depending on your driver profile, where you live in Illinois, your vehicle, and how many discounts you qualify for, you could see full-coverage rates well below state averages. For minimum liability coverage, the difference is even more dramatic.
To get the cheapest car auto insurance in Illinois USA, get multiple quotes, consider minimum coverage if appropriate, make use of discounts, maintain a clean driving record, and review your policy annually.